N.A. Reiter, L.L. Schillig
6 January, 2002
Background:
In 1999, we discovered references from the 1970’s concerning a purported anti-gravity or weight
alteration anomaly discovered by Thomas Townsend Brown, who is more famously known among the New Science community
for his work with electrical field propulsion. In a little known document, available on the Thomas Townsend Brown
Family Website, Brown described what he called a
"tribo-gravitic effect". This effect concerned the anomalous weight loss/recovery of granulated dielectric media -
particularly finely divided clays and oxides when agitated for periods of time in sealed vessels.
In a series of experiments in our lab, we were able to repeat this effect to our satisfaction by
ultrasonically agitating sealed tubes containing various powders. Ultimately, however, we found evidence that the
weight loss/recovery effect we were seeing (typically between 1 and 20 milligrams) was likely due to warm air
buoyancy or convective air current around the ampoules used. We set the experiments and the concepts aside and
tentatively considered the case closed. However, there were two somewhat enigmatic aspects of the effect that
remained in our minds. First, the weight loss/recovery effect was more dramatic for a given material when a
finer-grained version of said material was agitated. For example, 30 micron Al2O3 media gave a much greater
magnitude of effect than 1 to 2 mm irregular shot. Secondly, the effect went away entirely when small amounts of
water were added to the material being agitated, despite the heating action of the ultrasonic bath which we
presumed was the energy source for the thermal artifacts we felt were behind the effect.
Our Initial Nano-particle Observations:
In summer of 2001, we procured for general experimentation a 100 gram quantity of TiO2
nano-particle media from Altair Technologies in Nevada. The TiNano40 - RPC-D product is a stable, white,
ultra-fine titania powder with an average particle diameter of between 35 and 50 nm (350 to 500 angstroms).
In early December of 2001, it occurred to us that perhaps we had been too hasty in our write-off
of the Brown "Tribo-gravitic" effect. Might there have been some genuine anomaly present that had been partially
obscured by a thermal artifact? We had pondered why an enhanced effect had been seen with more finely divided
materials. On a whim, we took a quantity of about 80 grams of our TiNano nano-particle media and placed it in a
polycarbonate bottle with a vapor seal.
The bottle was weighed on our Ainsworth CL-204 Digital balance with a resolution of .1 milligrams.
We then took the bottle and vigorously and randomly shook it for about 30 seconds. Upon re-weighing, we found
that the bottle was approximately 2 milligrams lighter. The weight loss did not appear to recover. We
suspected that perhaps a few nano-particles had leaked past the seal. Several wraps of Kapton tape were added to
the lid interface to make a secondary seal. The procedure was repeated, and again - a weight loss of 1.3
milligrams was seen. We repeated the operation a number of times and tried weighing the bottle on our mechanical
Stanton Unimatic balance. While the weight loss amount varied, each shaking procedure would induce a further (and
apparently permanent) weight loss of between .2 and 2 milligrams.
Were we losing discrete amounts of the media through small fissures or cracks in the plastic
bottle? Or was something very peculiar happening?
Our Further Experiments:
On 10 December, we took about 20 grams of the TiNano media and sealed it into a Pyrex ampoule of
25mm OD and 120mm length. Before filling and sealing, the ampoule was rinsed with DI water, MeOH, and was oven
dried for 2 hours. We then filled the ampoule and allowed a further drying period at 200C for 30 minutes. After
sealing, we performed a visual inspection to confirm the integrity of our glass seal points.
The ampoule was allowed to cool to room temperature. We then wrapped it completely in aluminum
foil to provide a shield against electrostatic charges that might build up from agitation of the dielectric
TiO2.
We weighed the ampoule assembly and found a baseline weight of 56.7484 grams. The ampoule was
then shaken violently by hand for 1-minute periods. We then performed post shake weighing on both the Ainsworth
and Stanton balances (Since the Stanton balance is mechanical, we considered ½ division, or .5milligram, to be
the smallest useful unit there.)
Essentially, the effect remained present, with the post weight dropping each time by amounts
varying from between .1 to .8 milligrams.
On 11 December, we placed about 40 grams of an aqueous suspended TiNano 40 (procured at the same
time as the dry version) in a double-sealed bottle and ran through the weighing-shaking-weighing protocol. In the
case of the suspended nano-particles, we saw NO discernible net weight changes! Thus, it would appear as though
the effect manifests only with discrete (dry) solid phase nano-particles.
On 12 December, we disclosed the basics of the effect to Scott Little and Hal Puthoff of
Earthtech in Austin, Texas. In the past, we have informally collaborated with Earthech and consider them to be a
highly valuable resource on all matters involving Quantum Vacuum Engineering, propulsion, and new energy
conversion schemes. Scott replied with an interesting possibility tendered, pending better confirmation - the
possibility of macroscopic quantum tunneling! This had not occurred to us, but it certainly appeared to represent
a viable option. Could kinetically randomized nano-particles tunnel through a glass or plastic ampoule?
This was explored. On 14 December, we took our larger sealed plastic bottle and weighed it on our
Stanton balance. (120.512g) We then proceeded to give the bottle a 30-second manual agitation over an 8" by 8"
piece of clean black laser light absorbing paper. Upon re-weighing, we found a 1.5 milligram loss. The laser
absorber, however, was clean. This operation was repeated several times. No sign of TiNano media was to be found
on the paper. After some deliberation, we considered the possibility that if some nano-particles were tunneling,
then enough of their kinetic energy might remain on the outboard side of the ampoule to project further away than
the eight inch square of paper would catch.
We then took our sealed bottle and placed it inside of a zip-locked plastic baggie. A 30 second
agitation was given, and upon re-weighing, we found that a little over 1 milligram of weight had been lost.
However, to our visual discernment, no nano-particle media appeared between the bottle and the baggie. One might
argue that if selected nano-particles were tunneling through the bottle, then could they not have tunneled through
the outer baggie as well? Possibly. Our intuition would suggest that by probability, though, most of the tunneled
particles should have stayed inside the outer barrier.
If nothing else, these observations bolstered the argument against the effect being due to an
artifact of unforeseen leakage of a conventional sort through micro-cracks or flaws in ampoule or bottle.
During the experiments with the black laser absorber, a startling observation was made that could
imply the presence of quantum mechanical principles at work. We believe that we may have witnessed the Quantum
Zeno Effect.
Essentially, we found that when the agitation of the bottle over the laser absorber was performed
whilst watching intently, the magnitude of the post weight loss was either null or reduced. Shaking whilst not
looking, even over the black absorber, produced a weight loss. This effect was repeated four times on 14 December,
and we would be remiss if we did not state that it led to a considerable amount of mental consternation!
We recognize that this is an incredibly controversial statement and have made it a point to
continue examining further experimental results with this material in light of it.
Overall, the impression one receives is that if the weight loss is due to an anomalous departure
of nano-particle media from the bottle, it is not a short-range re-location. By 18 December, we had observed that
the repeated shaking and weighing trials did seem to be having a cumulative effect on the overall sample weight.
On 20 December, we recorded the total weight of the sealed polycarbonate bottled sample to be 120.488 grams.
A suggestion was made by Dr. Puthoff of EarthTech to try placing the bottled nano-particle media
on an automated shaker and allowing a long period of agitation to transpire, thus producing a visible or total
diminishing of the TiNano 40. We followed through with this and made the following observations:
- Gentle tumbling or simple vibratory agitation of the media did not produce any noticeable weight
alterations - even after up to 30 minute periods.
- We were finally able to find a mechanical motion that produced weight reduction, though at a reduced
magnitude from a good manual shaking. We placed the bottle of TiNano between two of the three clamps of a
large shop lathe and spun the lathe at about 120 rpm. The resulting motion provided a thorough, though not
forceful, eccentric tumbling action.
- For the first fifteen-minute tumble, we found a weight diminishment of 2.5 milligrams - roughly what a
vigorous one-minute manual shaking would incur.
- Further fifteen-minute tumbling periods produced incrementally lesser magnitudes of weight loss. By period
four (1 hour total time), no further significant weight change could be measured with the Stanton balance.
This experiment led us to reconsider the role of potential artifacts, primarily subtle thermal
effects. From 15 December to 27 December, we tried a variety of tests intended to induce weight alteration
artifacts by heating. The outcome of this testing was the confirmation that a pre-heating of the bottle interior
by an infrared lamp or cooling by placing in a freezer did shift the net weight of the bottle by up to 10
milligrams. However, we also observed that even in these conditions, the weight loss by agitation of the TiNano
was apparent at its typical level. We were also able to confirm that cupping the sample bottle in a bare hand for
60 seconds without agitation did not produce any observable deviation upon re-weighing.
We continued to question the essential character of the weight loss. Was it truly permanent,
implying either an anomalous departure of mass from the bottle (quantum tunneling? teleportation?), or was it a
weight alteration requiring an enormously long time (hours to days) to return to normal? By 4 January, 2002, our
opinion was that the weight changes appeared to be partially recoverable. A typical shaking might reduce
the sample weight by 2 milligrams. If one locked the stirrup of the balance to relieve strain and came back four
hours later, one might see that perhaps half of the value has returned - leaving the sample with a net permanent
loss of about a milligram! There was no way to deny the fact that the total weight of the TiNano media and
polycarbonate sample bottle was gradually diminishing.
Another valuable clue was derived by testing different finely divided media. We used a fresh
polycarbonate bottle with vapor seal and used a protocol consisting of weighing - 60 second agitation -
re-weighing. Among the different materials tested were:
- Granular salt
- Granular gelatin
- Industrial glass bead
- Powdered zinc
- Powdered nickel
- Baking soda
- Corn starch
- Molybdenum trioxide powder (200 mesh)
- 30 micron Al2O3 bead
Comparable weights of all materials were used. We found that out of these, the only material that
experienced a noticeable weight alteration was the corn starch. In magnitude, the weight loss for an equivalent
starting weight seemed to be typically about half the value of the TiNano. However, this may provide an avenue for
those who wish to replicate the effect and do not have the ability to procure titania nano-particles.
This also further demonstrates that something truly related to size scale is going on! We found
assorted references on-line to the average size of corn starch grains as lying between .5 and 5 microns. If this
is so, then we would safely be able to say that out of the materials tested, the corn starch was likely the
closest to the TiNano in grain size.
Two other observations merit reporting here. First, we were able to conclude, after many test
cycles, that the magnitude of weight loss appears to be proportional to the general magnitude of changes in
acceleration - the vigorousness and abruptness of shaking. Additionally, it appears as though maximum effects are
achieved by maximizing the randomness of the orientation! An orderly linear oscillation by hand does not produce
as great a weight alteration as a wild, chaotic shifting of directions and amplitudes.
Secondly, we note that the amplitude of the effect appears to be subject to further unknown
influences outside of those mentioned already. Two mornings in early January were logged where regardless of the
vigor of shaking the weight loss effect appeared to be gone. It returned later in the day. No appreciable changes
in temperature, barometric pressure, or humidity in the lab could be cited as correlating. Another factor may
relate to the experience related earlier dealing with a possible observational influence. We have continued to
witness this sort of an influence. While we are currently focusing on trying to verify this admittedly difficult
aspect, we will state for the record that there appears to be an enhancement of the weight loss if a particular
mental state is maintained during the agitation. The details of this state are being clarified, but in short it
is one of chaotic anxiety or mental agitation - roughly the consciousness - equivalent of the physical action
being provided to the media!
As this report is being tendered, further examination of this enigmatic effect continues.
Hypothesis and Discussion:
If we are to say that the enigmatic results of these experiments are genuine, then what basis
could exist to explain them?
One turns first to historical observations and precedent. As mentioned previously, Thomas
Townsend Brown may have observed this effect or variations of it in his experiments in the early 1970’s. However,
Brown was clearly perplexed by the nature of what he saw and confessed to have no theoretical opinion of it apart
from what might relate to his ideas concerning rock-electricity and massive dielectric transducers of gravity
waves.
In December of 2001, however, we did find one other reference to (apparently) our nano-particle
effect - one that may offer a valuable insight!
In a paper from 1967 by the Soviet lunar astronomer and time theorist, Nikolai Kozyrev, the author describes some of the experimental evidence acquired
supporting his theoretical model of a universal time energy. In more recent years, Kozyrev's model has been
considered a viable alternative model for dark energy or the Zero Point Field.
Kozyrev makes an interesting statement near the end of his paper. He mentions an experiment used
to illustrate the effects of a disruption of time energy flow into or out of mass. This experiment bears a
striking resemblance to our effect. Kozyrev claims that a mass that is oscillated along an axis with considerable
magnitude will experience a temporary weight loss. This weight alteration may be seen if one is nimble enough to
place the mass quickly onto a balance. Kozyrev furthermore states that there exists a period of time during which
the weight of the mass will re-normalize or return to its starting value. This period appeared to be dependent on
the density of the mass. High-density masses such as lead would re-normalize within a few seconds at
most. Wood or cellulose would take up to over a minute.
If we consider that the virtual density of nano-particle media is incredibly low, might we
consider that Kozyrev's weight return time for such a material could be in hours?
At this time, we make the following statements concerning our observations:
- TiO2 (titania) nano-particle media placed in a sealed vessel will exhibit a small but anomalous weight
loss following a period of high amplitude agitation.
- The magnitude of this weight loss has typically been in the range of fractional to several milligrams for
samples of media up to 80 grams.
- At least a portion of this weight alteration seems irreversible. In some cases, a partial weight return
with a period of > than 1 hour has been noted.
- Other nano-particle or near-nano scale materials can exhibit this property. The effect appears to not
exist with samples of granular media having diameters larger than a few microns.
- The effect appears to stand apart from thermal and convection weight change artifacts.
- A variety of unknown factors may influence the magnitude of the effect. We have observed actions that may
imply observer interaction or the Quantum Zeno Effect.
Primarily leaning on statements 3, 4, and 6 above, we offer a model for the effect based on the
fundamental principle of Quantum Uncertainty. It is our hypothesis that under certain ambient conditions,
nano-particle matter could display peculiar properties and high levels of quantum uncertainty. While normal
aggregates of solid phase matter typically do not display uncertainty, we suggest that chaotically agitated
volumes of nano-particles may. We furthermore suggest that when nano-particles are violently agitated in a chaotic
or nonlinear fashion, uncertainty for both position and momentum may become so great that the nano-particle wave
function collapses entirely, mass is driven to zero, and the nano-particle effectively vanishes. In other
instances, there may exist a state of near-collapse that may be able to stabilize somehow with time, thus
returning a nano-particle mass back to a state of "certainty". Yet another possibility could exist in which the
uncertain particle might spontaneously and randomly teleport!
Given this mechanism, applied probabilistically to a comparatively large, loose aggregate of
nano-particles, we would predict that after a period of violent, chaotic agitation, a small number of the total
aggregate will vanish - some permanently, some with a chance to return.
The potential for a "near-collapse" raises a number of speculations itself. If a particle or mass
existed in this state, would it be somewhat ghost-like? Would the influence or coupling of gravitons be
disrupted, thus contributing to an overall weight loss?
We freely confess that this model or hypothesis is still not firmly constructed. Our primary
focus for now remains empirical. Only further experimentation will allow us to construct a proper model - our own
as well as those replications that we hope will occur with the dissemination of this report!
In closing, we would like to acknowledge the help and input of Scott Little and Dr. Hal Puthoff of
EarthTech International and George Hathaway of Toronto. Additional credit is also given to Altair Technologies of
Reno, Nevada, for their generous policy of providing research samples of their products.
References
- "Method for Producing Gravitationally Anomalous Materials" Thomas Townsend Brown, unpublished document,
April 1973, reproduced on the TT Brown Family
website.
- "The Possibility of Experimental Study of the Properties of Time" Nikolai A. Kozyrev, unpublished
document, September 1967
Back to top |